Book Reviews

Go To Hopkins & Company Homepage

Go to Executive Times Archives

 

Scarlet Feather by Maeve Binchy

 

Recommendation:

 

Click on title or picture to buy from amazon.com

 

 

Dublin’s Fair City

I remained distracted reading the first hundred or so pages of Maeve Binchy’s new novel, Scarlet Feather. It may have been the introduction of too many characters with too many links among them to keep straight. Once I became comfortable with the characters, I fell into this novel wholeheartedly, and wished it would not end. Binchy tells the story mostly through dialogue, and the many voices add a richness to the story. Tom Feather and Cathy Scarlet attended cooking school together, and have opened a new catering business in Dublin, called Scarlet Feather. The novel takes us month by month through the first year of their business, during which all relationships have complicated ups and downs in the many extended families we come to know in the novel.

Binchy creates believable characters who care for each other, but with the Irish tendency to not show it. Each scene is packed with energy and tension that Binchy carries off with aplomb. Cathy married Neil Mitchell, an attorney, whose parents had employed Cathy’s mother as a maid. Here’s a scene of Cathy having lunch with her overbearing mother-in-law:

“’Do explain what you mean, Mrs. Mitchell.’
’It’s just that I’m asking myself why does Neil go out so much for work, why do you not have a social life, give dinner parties, go to clubs? I mean are you a member of any clubs, tell me? It’s just, I worry when a young couple don’t have a healthy social life. One begins to wonder why.’
’We both work fairly hard, and I think we can safely say that Neil cares hugely about his clients and about justice being done, so this naturally takes up a lot of his time. I think that must be it, don’t you?’
’Well, yes, of course, of course, that goes without saying, it’s just that I wondered, perhaps, if you were to…Well if you were to try and…’ She seemed to lose the words.
’If I were to what, Mrs. Mitchell?’ Cathy was genuinely interested now. What on earth was the woman going to suggest? That Cathy should learn some new and devastating sexual techniques, or give dinner parties twice a week inviting politicians and the media? She waited with interest.
’Well, that you should smarten yourself up a little.’ Mrs. Mitchell was diffident. But once she had said it she was sticking to it. ‘It’s just that possibly you’ve been so busy with work and everything…that you haven’t had time to stop and take a good look at yourself.’
Cathy did not know whether to feel humiliated or amused. It was so patronizing for one woman to tell another that she need to clean up her act. Yet this advice was being given by a woman aged sixty, with her hair scraped up in a style that was ten years out of date, squeezed into a wool suit one size too small, wearing a nail color that had not been seen outside pantomime for decades. Hannah Mitchell, whose hard, made-over face and mink coat made her a caricature was daring to offer Cathy advice.
’And where do you think I could start? she asked in a level voice.
’Well, your hair, of course, and to show you how much I really mean it I’ve got you a gift certificate for Hayward’s.’ Mrs. Mitchell pulled out an envelope.
’I can’t possibly accept this,’ Cathy began.
’But you must. I don’t think I gave you a proper Christmas present, and let this be it. You did such a delightful job catering our New Year’s Eve party, a lot of people have spoken of it so well since. The very least I can do is start you off on some kind of makeover.’
Cathy stared glumly at the envelope.
’And do get your nails done at the same time, have nail extension maybe, won’t you? There’s a good girl. If there’s anything a man likes to see on a woman, it’s long, groomed nails.’
’You know, Mrs. Mitchell, I’ll certainly think about the hairdo but if you don’t mind, I think I’ll pass on the nails. You see in our job nail extensions would be a bit dangerous---we could lose them making pastry, for example.’ Cathy tried to be lighthearted. It was the only alternative to doing what he really felt like doing which was standing up and pushing over the dining table into her mother-in-law’s lap.
’Well.’ Mrs. Mitchell sounded sad and disappointed, as someone who had done her best but failed in the end, thanks to Cathy’s gross stupidity.
’But truly I am grateful for your kindness, Mrs. Mitchell. And for this lunch.
They had just put the fish in front of them, and Hannah was looking at it suspiciously. ‘Is it properly filleted?’ she asked the waiter.
’I hope so madam. Very often a tiny bone escapes, but I think you will find great care has been taken.’ Cathy winked at the waiter as Hannah peered at her plate. She knew him well from her nights working here. He kept a solemn face. Brenda Brennan ran a tight ship at Quentin’s He didn’t want to be spotted mocking the customers.”

Scarlet Feather is full of abundant scenes like this one, full of good dialogue and restrained emotion. Enjoy reading it.

Steve Hopkins, May 10, 2001

 

ã 2001 Hopkins and Company, LLC